When U.S. Customs officials in Arizona called Van Doren Rubber Co. last August to notify the company that a shipment of counterfeit Vans athletic shoes had been seized, officials at the suburban Orange-based company were not surprised.

Not only did the company know its goods were being counterfeited, it had already joined forces with two competitors - Reebok and Converse - in an unprecedented joint investigation to find out who was responsible.The international probe involved a remarkable degree of cooperation among three rivals in the fiercely competitive athletic shoe business and among law enforcement officials in the United States, Mexico and Chile, according to attorneys involved in the case.

It culminated in Friday's indictment of 18 individuals, including eight San Diego County residents and three South Korean businessmen, on charges of trafficking in counterfeit goods, money laundering and making false statements to customs authorities. The conspirators allegedly sold millions of pairs of counterfeit sneakers bearing the labels of Reebok, Converse, Vans, L.A. Gear and others through two rings in San Diego.

Stephen M. McNamee, U.S. Attorney for the district of Phoenix, said the criminal investigation began in August when Mexican customs agents refused to allow the importation of a shipment of athletic shoes from Korea. U.S. Customs agents at the international port of entry in Nogales, Ariz., examined the rejected goods and found sneakers with the "Vans" label in boxes indicating that they were manufactured in Korea.

But Vans shoes are all made by the Van Doren Rubber Co. at its plant in Orange, and customs agents notified the company that they had seized what appeared to be counterfeit goods. Vans, in the meantime, was engaged in a private investigation of counterfeiting in conjunction with Reebok and Converse, and the three firms were able to provide valuable information to law enforcement authorities.

The investigation was spearheaded by New York attorney Harley I. Lewin, who initially had been retained by Reebok. Converse eventually joined in the investigation after discussions among the attorneys. Vans became involved when it asked its local attorney to look into the counterfeiting problem, and the attorney approached Lewin.

View Comments

"Counterfeiting is expensive for us," said Richard Leeuwenburg, president of Van Doren."It costs us well in excess of $1 million a year."

"They all decided it would be best to pool information," Lewin said. "Doing this kind of investigation, which involves attorneys and investigators in multiple countries, is very expensive." He declined to say how much had been spent by the three companies.

Lewin said the investigation included substantial undercover work involving people posing as buyers and sellers of athletic shoes. That effort, combined with the efforts of Mexican customs authorities, brought about the arrests of Coronado, Calif., residents Nathan and Marcos Betech in Mexico City last September.

At the same time, authorities in San Diego raided the Betech companies' offices there in response to civil lawsuits initiated by Lewin on behalf Reebok, Converse and Vans, and a federal judge subsequently ordered a freeze on all the assets of the Be-tech firms, known as Marnatech Enterprises Inc. and Conatech S.A.

Join the Conversation
Looking for comments?
Find comments in their new home! Click the buttons at the top or within the article to view them — or use the button below for quick access.