Sen. Jake Garn, R-Utah, is probably President Bush's 12th most favorite senator. On the other end of the spectrum, Rep. Wayne Owens, D-Utah, probably is Bush's 373rd most preferred out of 435 House members.

A new study by Congressional Quarterly shows how often members of Congress voted in 1989 to support Bush on issues where he announced a stand - and also showed how often they missed votes, how often they voted along party lines and how often they supported the "conservative coalition."Garn voted to support Bush 89 percent of the time, 12th highest among the 100 senators. Sen. Orrin Hatch, R-Utah, supported Bush 82 percent of the time, 28th best in the Senate.

On the House side, Owens was one of Bush's strongest adversaries. He supported Bush only 30 percent of the time, ranking him 373rd out of 435.

Rep. Jim Hansen, R-Utah, was Bush's 15th strongest House supporter, voting for his positions 82 percent of the time. Rep. Howard Nielson, R-Utah, supported Bush 76 percent of the time, 65th strongest in the House.

The average congressional support of Bush in 1989 was 63 percent - the lowest for a first-year elected president since such studies began in 1953. Still that was much higher than the 47.4 percent support Reagan had during his last year in office. In 1988, Garn was the second strongest Senate supporter of Reagan, backing him 85 percent of the time. He supported Bush more often than that, but other Senators supported Bush even more strongly. Hatch also backed Reagan 82 percent in 1988 - which then was good enough to make him Reagan's sixth strongest Senate ally.

The new study also shows that members of Utah's delegation often vote along party lines, and that all but Owens usually vote with the "conservative coalition" of Republicans and southern Democrats when it appears to oppose initiatives by northern Democrats.

Utah congressmen missed few votes. Hatch voted 99 percent of the time; Nielson, 97 percent; Garn and Hansen, 96 percent; and Owens, 90 percent.

But other congressmen voted even more often. In fact, Garn's 96 percent score allowed him to finish only 90th out of 100 in the Senate. Owens' 90 percent made him finish 395th out of 435 in the House.

Hatch voted with the conservative coalition 97 percent of the time (second highest in the Senate); Garn, 95 percent (seventh highest in the Senate); Hansen, 98 percent; (13th highest in the House); Nielson, 95 percent; and Owens, only 20 percent.

*****

(Additional information)

1989 tally

The 1989 voting record of Utah's congressmen:

Votes supporting

Bush stands:

Garn 89 percent

Hatch 82 percent

Hansen 82 percent

Nielson 76 percent

Owens 30 percent

Voting participation record

Garn 96 percent

Hatch 99 percent

Hansen 96 percent

Nielson 97 percent

Owens 90 percent

Party-line votes

Garn 97 percent

Hatch 85 percent

Hansen 93 percent

Nielson 84 percent

Owens 96 percent

Votes supporting

"conservative

coalition"

Garn 95 percent

View Comments

Hatch 97 percent

Hansen 98 percent

Nielson 95 percent

Owens 20 percent

Join the Conversation
We’re testing some changes to our moderation system. You’ll see two changes:
  1. Fewer comments automatically sent to moderation (we hope).
  2. Lower tolerance for uncivil comments. If you encounter a warning that your comment will be sent to moderation, try revising before you submit for the best chance of approval.
Your feedback is welcome and can be submitted here.
Looking for comments?
Find comments in their new home! Click the buttons at the top or within the article to view them — or use the button below for quick access.