An attorney's bid to ask the governor what he was told about the death of an inmate in a restraining chair was quashed Oct. 16 by a federal judge.
Ross C. Anderson said he wanted to subpoena Gov. Mike Leavitt and his deputy chief of staff and press aide Vicki Varela to find out how prison officials arrived at their justification for the use of the chair on inmate Michael D. Valent.Anderson claims prison officials have been offering conflicting versions of what led up to the decision to strap Valent in the device for 16 hours on March 20. A short time later, Valent, 19, died of blood clots that were blamed on the restraints that constricted circulation in his legs and arms.
His mother, Angela M. Armstrong, later filed a lawsuit against prison officials and the manufacturer of the chair, alleging a violation of her son's constitutional rights, negligence and product liability. Filed in May in state court, Armstrong's lawsuit was subsequently transferred to federal court.
The Department of Corrections quit using the chair in April.
At a hearing before U.S. District Senior Judge Bruce Jenkins, Anderson said he needs to question the governor to unravel the official "spin" that corrections officials put on the story.
Shortly after Valent's death, a prison spokesman told reporters that Valent was placed in the restraining chair to stop him from banging his head, arms and legs against his cell walls. Later, officials said they resorted to the chair when Valent, who had recently been taken off his regular medication, was found with a pillow case over his head.
They assert that Valent swatted the hand of an officer who tried to remove the pillow case and then adopted a "fighting stance," Anderson said.
The governor and Varela may be able to shed some light on how prison officials "came up with this story," Anderson said, suggesting that the public has been deceived by "misrepresentations" fed to the media by prison spokesman Jack Ford.