First team
Offense
QB — Jim McMahon (1977-78, 80-81)
RB — Pete Van Valkenburg (1970-72)
RB — Jamal Willis (1991-94)
WR — Margin Hooks (1997-2000)
WR — Eric Drage (1990-93)
WR — Glen Kozlowski (1981, 83-85)
TE — Clay Brown (1978-80)
OL — Mo Elewonibi (1988-89)
OL — John Tait (1996-98)
OL — Trevor Matich (1979-80, 83-84)
OL — Bart Oates (1980-82)
OL — Larry Moore (1995-96)
Defensive
DL — Jason Buck (1985-86)
DL — Mat Mendenhall (1975-79)
DL — Shawn Knight (1983-86)
DL — Glen Titensor (1979-80)
LB — Todd Shell (1980-83)
LB — Kurt Gouveia (1983-85)
LB — Rob Morris (1993, 1997-99)
LB — Leon White (1982-85)
DB — Tom Holmoe (1979-82)
DB — Derwin Gray (1989-92)
DB — Brian Mitchell (1987-90)
DB — Kyle Morrell (1981-84)
Specialists
K — Owen Pochman (1997-2000)
P — Lee Johnson (1981-84)
RS — Vai Sikahema (1980-85)
Second team
Offense
QB — Ty Detmer (1988-91)
— Steve Young (1981-83)
RB — Todd Christensen (1974-77)
RB — Jeff Blanc (1973-76)
RB — Lakei Heimuli (1983-86)
WR — Mark Bellini (1982, 84-86)
WR — Jay Miller (1972-74, 76)
TE — Gordon Hudson (1981-83)
OL — Brad Oates (1973-75)
OL — Nick Eyre (1976, 78-80)
OL — Evan Pilgrim (1991-94)
OL — Tom Bell (1977-79)
OL — Scott Brumfield (1991-92)
Defensive
DL — Brad Anae (1980-81)
DL — Jim Herrmann (1981, 83-84)
DL — Daren Yancey (1995-98)
DL — Travis Hall (1991-94)
LB — Kyle Whittingham (1978-81)
LB — Rocky Biegel (1988-91)
LB — Shay Muirbrook (1993-96)
LB — Bob Davis (1987-89)
DB — Troy Long (1985-88)
DB — Omarr Morgan (1996-97)
DB — Tim McTyer (1995-96)
DB — Brian Gray (1998-99)
Specialists
K — Leonard Chitty (1986-87)
P — Earl Kauffman (1988-91)
RS — James Dye (1995-96)