clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Californians stunned that Elizabeth was among them

SAN DIEGO — He called himself Emmanuel and claimed to be divine. For several weeks, residents of Lakeside, a rural community near San Diego, noticed the bearded man in a long tunic who walked the streets and preached the gospel.

The two women who followed him, covered in robes and veils, spoke to no one.

"We never associated them with the missing girl in Utah," said Terri Sparks, who often saw the trio as they walked past the recycling station she runs in a store parking lot.

On Thursday, people in the unincorporated town 25 miles east of downtown San Diego said they were shocked to learn that the girl was Elizabeth Smart, the Utah teenager who had been missing since June. She was found in Utah on Wednesday and reunited with her family.

The man known as Emmanuel has been identified as Brian David Mitchell, a drifter who once worked at the Smart family's home. He and his wife, Wanda Barzee, were jailed on suspicion of aggravated kidnapping.

The revelation that the missing girl had been living in plain sight also came as a surprise to local law-enforcement authorities, who had Mitchell in custody a month ago.

Under the alias of Michael Jensen, Mitchell was arrested by San Diego County Sheriff's deputies on Feb. 12 for vandalizing a Lakeside church, sheriff and FBI sources said. He pleaded guilty, was released on probation Feb. 18 and fined $250, FBI spokeswoman Jan Caldwell said. It's not clear from court records whether he paid the fine.

Fingerprint comparisons Thursday showed that Mitchell and Jensen were the same person, Caldwell said.

Sheriff's spokesman Chris Saunders said a fingerprint check done after the arrest indicated he was also known as Mitchell, but deputies had no reason to keep him in custody.

"There were no warrants on him. There was no reason to hold him," Saunders said.

"If we had to do it over again, there's really nothing different we could have done because Salt Lake City authorities didn't identify him as a suspect until March 1."

Merchants and transients near Lindo Lake, in the center of Lakeside, said they first noticed the man and two women last fall. Some thought they had seen them here as recently as two weeks ago.

The three largely kept to themselves, especially the woman and the girl. The man known as Emmanuel claimed the girl was his daughter.

"Hey, did you hear about Emmanuel? He had kidnapped that girl," Roger Ruis, a 39-year-old homeless man, told friends gathered at a park where the trio routinely spent their days.

"They were always very pleasant," said Richard Mason, a 45-year-old homeless man. "She didn't seem like she was kidnapped. She acted like she was part of the family."

The three sometimes ate lunch next to the lake, where on Thursday mothers played with children and passers-by fed sandwich bread to ducks and geese. The woman and girl would keep their veils on even when eating.

"The only part of the body you could see was their eyes," said John Neal, a 40-year-old homeless man. "We were joking about it. We thought it was pretty strange."

They often were seen walking or riding buses.

Richard Mason, a 45-year-old transient, said they sometimes slept under a highway bridge near a river bed where many homeless camp at night. On Thursday, the FBI was searching a campsite reportedly used by Mitchell in Santee, four miles from Lakeside.

Many who spoke to Mitchell said he passed out religious fliers and attempted to preach to them. Clay Ruis, 47, said he asked once if the women wore veils because they were Muslim.

"He said, 'No. The women are veiled to protect them from the sins of the world,' " he recalled.

Speaking once about the name "Emmanuel," Clay Ruis said he noted it means "God is with us." Mitchell responded, "Yes, I am that person."

Several of the transients said Mitchell liked to drink beer. When he did, he would preach more fervently and claim to be Jesus Christ.

Rafe Potres, the owner of a convenience store across from the lake, said Mitchell came in daily to buy a large can of a high-alcohol-content beer. He would ask the women if they wanted something to drink.

"They would say not a single word. All they did was nod their heads," Potres said.

Elizabeth would select a can of Sierra Mist soda, and Emmanuel would pay with change he pulled out of a cloth pouch.

Potres said he was disturbed to learn that Elizabeth had been in his store and he had not made the connection.

"I could have done something, you know?" he said. "The next time someone raises my suspicion, I'm going to think twice."