Maybe you've noticed. Almost overnight we have become one eNation, under God, with Liberty and Twitter for all.

How's eLife treating you? Do you Facebook, Google, MySpace, Flickr, Twitter, blog, Skype, Yahoo, text, e-mail, YouTube, Wii, Warcraft? Or are you still learning Pong?

All this technology has changed the world, but here's what I wonder: Is it progress?

Admittedly, I don't have much of an eLife. I don't Twitter, Skype or Wii, and I thought Flickr was a horse. I don't know what to do when I receive e-mails that say, "Bob has added you as a friend on Facebook." And this means what?

So maybe I'm missing out. But I don't really believe that.

I can't help but think we're losing something as we're drawn inexorably down the eHighway. I realize much of it has value, but I wonder if it's worth the trade-offs.

You can make friends without ever seeing their faces or hearing their voices. Teen boys prefer to ask girls on dates via text. Isn't he missing out if he doesn't experience the anxiety and risk of asking a girl to the movies while looking into her eyes — or at least her shoes?

You can "play" sports and never leave the house or break a sweat. How can Wii and Madden replace pickup games in the driveway or back yard, learning to get along, being part of a team, hustling and developing our bodies? I can hear our kids getting fatter.

You can replace social interaction by meeting people online from the safety of your home. I read recently that if MySpace were a country, it would be the fifth largest in the world. Isn't there some merit in meeting people personally and enjoying their physical presence?

You can waste your time being entertained on the Web and never develop talents or your knowledge. You can become a virtual musician by playing Guitar Hero and never have to practice. But pressing colored buttons on a plastic guitar isn't the same thing as learning to play the real thing. That's the way it is with shortcuts. Every kid should have his mother nag him this question: "Have you practiced piano today?"

Someone actually said this to me in defense of the eLife: "Maybe somebody doesn't play piano, but instead they cut and recut music digitally. We have to get over preset notions." How can that compare to the pleasure of hearing yourself play "Canon in D" on the piano with your own hands, or even "Chopsticks" for that matter?

We can avoid facing our shortcomings by going online and becoming someone else in "virtual reality" worlds. Country singer Brad Paisley sang it best: "I'm 5 foot 3 and overweight, I'm a sci-fi fanatic, A mild asthmatic, And I've never been to second base, But there's whole 'nother me, That you need to see, Go check out MySpace. 'Cause online I'm out in Hollywood, I'm 6 foot 5 and I look damn good, I drive a Maserati, I'm a black-belt in karate."

You can avoid dealing with issues in your family or marriage by creating cyber families. But how does that compare with a makeup hug or a cathartic talk with your kids or dinner with your wife? How can fake relationships replace the real thing? According to a survey of 30,000 online gamers by a Stanford Ph.D., nearly 40 percent of men and 53 percent of women said their virtual friends were equal to or better than their real-life friends.

View Comments

You could go through life and not experience life.

Annie Maxfield taught a class at the University of Utah called "Living the eLife," which studies the complex ramifications of technology. While acknowledging pros and cons of the issue, she notes that the world has changed so quickly that "we end up using technologies without thinking about the repercussions. We don't think about what face-to-face conversation is like or how relationships are changing. (Technology) is so far ahead of where we are. We're always trying to catch up."

We've rushed headlong into a strange new world.

Doug Robinson's column runs on Tuesdays. Please send e-mail to drob@desnews.com

Join the Conversation
Looking for comments?
Find comments in their new home! Click the buttons at the top or within the article to view them — or use the button below for quick access.