As evening's pinkish-orange light descended on the cotton farms and cactus-dry mountains ringing the site of last week's deadly Amtrak derailment, locals at the Desert Rose bar swapped theories.

They weren't buying the FBI theory of sabotage, but not because of any anti-government sentiment. They wondered if the railway might be trying to cover up poor maintenance with talk of terrorists.Around them, the sky's glow didn't penetrate the window shades to lighten the walls decked with old snapshots of regulars, beer ads and plaques, including one picturing a gun and a saying: "We Don't Dial 911." Another: "Trying to keep a secret at the Desert Rose is like trying to slip daylight past a rooster."

The FBI believes saboteurs may be to blame for Monday's Sunset Limited derailment near Hyder that killed one person and injured 78, in part because a note found at the scene rails against abuses by federal law enforcement agencies and calls for an "independent federal agency" to watch the watchers.

"No one around here thinks like that. Not in Hyder, not here," John Kane, 36, said in Arlington, about 17 miles from the site. "They don't have those opinions."

"I don't believe it was sabotage," Kane said Thursday. "I think it's a ruse to divert attention from the fact that the tracks are not well maintained."

And the note?

"I dunno," Kane said, smiling and shrugging.

View Comments

Charlie Brune agreed there might be a cover-up.

"I'm not saying the derailment wasn't deliberate, but it wasn't a good track to begin with," said Brune, 40, who hunts quail and deer in the area. "My personal opinion is that it wasn't inspected."

The track's owner, Southern Pacific Railroad Co., said the line is inspected twice a week and was examined on the Thursday before the derailment.

The derailment site, nearly 20 miles from the nearest paved road, is usually a crossroads for wandering animals. These days, it's so busy that the crowds of officials, investigators and reporters sometimes make for mini-traffic jams in the midst of the desert.

Join the Conversation
Looking for comments?
Find comments in their new home! Click the buttons at the top or within the article to view them — or use the button below for quick access.