Shurtleff’s qualifications have been compared with Young’s. The highest degree both hold are law degrees. Shurtleff’s law degree is from the University of Utah, while Young’s is from Harvard Law School. But that’s where the similarities end.
SALT LAKE CITY — Utah Attorney General Mark Shurtleff still isn't talking about his decision to seek the University of Utah presidency, but reaction was mixed Tuesday to his candidacy.
"It's way outside the box that higher ed usually considers for candidates. I'm glad he's applied. I hope they take his application seriously," said Sen. Howard Stephenson, R-Draper, the head of the Senate Education Committee.
Stephenson said Shurtleff cares more about results than image and could help shift what he has described as a focus on awarding "degrees to nowhere" at the state's flagship university that leave too many students in debt and without jobs.
"We need leadership that will change that," Stephenson said, calling for "a non-academic at the helm."
But others said Shurtleff's lack of a background in academia makes him an unlikely choice.
"Certainly from a faculty perspective, I think it's very problematic," U. political science professor Matthew Burbank said. "He has some of the skills you would expect. He's been a public figure. He understands how to deal with the Legislature. He knows how to meet with various constituency groups."
Burbank said that's not likely to be seen as enough to run a campus. A university president, he said, also has to be seen as "the ultimate authority on campus," able to settle faculty and student issues, as well as sell the school's academic prowess to the private and public entities outside the state that award research grants.
U. dean of social and behavioral science Steve Ott served on the last presidential search committee that settled on Michael Young as a finalist. Young served seven years as the U.'s president before stepping down last May to be president of the University of Washington.
Ott said while anyone can apply for the president spot, the last search committee pretty much settled on final candidates who had experience in university administration. "When you look for a major Research One university president, what you're looking for is someone who has experience at the president's level at a lesser institution, or someone who possibly has been at a number-two level at a comparable institution," Ott said.
During the last search, Ott said even the semi-finalist list was totally made up of candidates who had served as leaders at other higher education institutions.
Ott said a president needs to have a wide variety of experience. They need to know how to deal with medical school issues and running a hospital, and know how to support research and be a charismatic fundraiser.
"The university president is not a position for just someone to step into," said Ott, who added the U. president needs to also understand how to keep the university high in national standing. "This is a very sophisticated operation. You need to keep up the reputation as a superb research institution in order to attract the big grant money for research."
Student leaders also agreed that the next U. president should have higher education leadership experience, but at least one student leader said he welcomed the news that Shurtleff had applied.
"I think it's great. I'm not necessarily for or against Shurtleff, but it can help broaden their pool of candidates," said University of Utah student-body Vice President Tobin Bennion. "One more option can't hurt."
Student-body President Meela Pack could not comment as she currently serves on the selection committee.
Bennion said with the U. now a member of the PAC-12, it will need a president who has past higher education experience. "We need someone that has experience within higher education so that it's not something that's new to them when they're representing an entire university."
Having discussed qualities, Bennion said U. student leaders believe the next president cannot be just another "politician or businessman."
Shurtleff confirmed his intention to seek the post on Monday through a spokesman. Since then, Shurtleff has declined to talk about his reasons for his decision, citing his respect for the university's selection process, which keeps its initial list of candidates confidential until it releases a list of finalists. That list is expected to be released by next spring.
There have been rumors about others being considered, including former Utah Gov. Michael Leavitt, current Southern Utah University President Michael Benson and Salt Lake County Mayor Peter Corroon.
"Someone did submit my name as a candidate for the presidency," Corroon said Tuesday evening, adding that he does not know who recommended him. He said he found out about the invitation through a letter from the consultant working with the university on the process. "Obviously it would be a great honor."
Corroon said he has not decided whether to pursue the invitation. "I'm in the official 'I'll think about it' stage right now, recognizing there's probably a broad field of really great candidates."
Benson did not respond to a call seeking comment.
A representative for Leavitt told the Deseret News that Leavitt had been nominated by someone, but Leavitt did not apply for the position, nor intends to apply. "He is deeply involved in his company," said Natalie Gochnour, spokeswoman for Leavitt Partners, a consulting firm that advises on issues of healthcare, Medicare and Medicaid, and private/public equity.
Shurtleff's qualifications have been compared with Young's. The highest degree both hold are law degrees. Shurtleff's law degree is from the University of Utah, while Young's is from Harvard Law School. But that's where the similarities end.
Shurtleff served as a Naval judge advocate and practiced law in private practice. He has also worked as a deputy county attorney and was elected to the Salt Lake County Commission. He then became an assistant attorney general before being elected Utah attorney general in 2000 and is the author of a historical novel about Dred Scott, the subject of a landmark legal case.
Young has served as a tenured professor of law. Before being U. president, Young was dean and professor of comparative law at George Washington University Law School. He also served more than 20 years as a professor at Columbia University. Before that, he clerked for the late U.S. Supreme Court Justice William H. Rehnquist. Young also held several positions at federal agencies and commission.
Shurtleff, who made a brief bid for the Senate in 2010 before withdrawing for personal reasons, had earlier said he was considering another run for attorney general, or a possible bid for Congress. His decision to apply for the U. presidency appears to put any political plans on hold.
The Utah Board of Regents established a 20-member search committee, which consists of members from the Board of Regents, U. Board of Trustees, faculty leaders and community representatives. The majority of the committee consists of faculty and university officials.
Contributing: Steve Fidel