Wilson, who still has records for most touchdowns in a game (five) and most points in a game (32) was best known for his 13-year career as a safety with the St. Louis Cardinals. The Rigby, Idaho, native was named All-Pro eight times, is famous for originating the safety blitz and went on to be inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame in 1978.
What most people don’t know about Wilson is that he nearly became a rival of legendary BYU coach LaVell Edwards, coming this close to being named the Utes’ head coach in 1974.
After six years as the Utah coach, Bill Meek had resigned and Utah was looking for his replacement. Meek’s second-to-last game was a home loss to BYU, which was coached by Edwards, in his second year as the Cougars’ coach. It was the second straight year the Cougars had defeated the Utes on their home field; Utah had beaten BYU the previous four years and 21 of the previous 26 years.
Wilson had retired from the NFL in 1972 and served as the Cardinals’ secondary coach in 1973. He was one of eight candidates for the open Ute job and was reportedly all set to be named the head coach in late January.
Among the other candidates were former Utes players Chet Franklin, Bud Tynes, Ken Vierra, Tom Lovat and Utes assistant Jim Hanifan.
On Jan. 15, Wilson was quoted as saying “I want the job” and Deseret News and Salt Lake Tribune stories eight days later said he was “expected” to be named coach and “all the way it appears to be Wilson.”
However, at the last minute, the day of the athletic board meeting when he was expected to be chosen as the new coach, Wilson took his name out of the running because of “family reasons.”
Turns out he had a son, Jed, who had been born with spina bifida and Wilson and his wife decided they didn’t want to take him out of his special school in St. Louis in order to move to Utah.
The story of Wilson’s son wasn’t made public at the time and I only know this because my father was in the University of Utah administration at the time and told me the story later.
But that was the kind of person Larry Wilson was, putting family before his career. His wife, Nancy, said this of him after he died:
“Larry Wilson was the kindest, most humble person that I will ever know. He was the most generous and gentle soul you would ever meet. To Larry it was always about everyone else and what he could do for them. And especially in the times we live, that’s something we could use more of today.”
When Wilson declined the job in ’74, Utah turned to Lovat, a former offensive lineman for the Utes, who had been an offensive line coach on Meek’s staff. Lovat ended up having a rough go in his three years, with records of 1-10, 1-10 and 3-8 and his career 5-28 mark is the worst in Ute football history. He was was replaced by Wayne Howard in 1977.
So what if Wilson had taken the job in 1974? We can only speculate. Would he have fared better than Lovat? Probably. Would BYU have beaten Utah 17 of the next 19 years? Perhaps not.
You have to figure that Wilson, with his famous name and influence from the Midwest and being well-known around the country, would have been able to attract players and perhaps put a dent in the Cougars’ success against the Utes. Or perhaps with no real head coaching experience, he wouldn’t have fared any better than Lovat.
Instead of becoming a coach, Wilson stayed with the Cardinals for the next three decades, working as the scouting director, personnel director, vice president and general manager, retiring in 2003.
Could Wilson have found success as a coach and prevented two decades of Ute mediocrity on the football field?
We’ll never know.