The Keebler elves have been experimenting with graham crackers, chocolate and marshmallows! Keebler's S'mores don't need a campfire to combine those tasty ingredients. The new cookies retail for $1.79 for a 9.5-ounce package.

Don Russell (married, five children at home, ages 6-16): "I assume most children will appreciate the thin marshmallow filling that Keebler puts in these new cookies. S'mores are plenty sweet and the graham wafer makes them rather crunchy. Each cookie will cost you 50 calories. If you're in a rut with some of your favorites, you might enjoy this little novelty."Edyth Jensen (married, three children at home): "Everyone in our family enjoyed these cookies. They're close to the flavor of real S'mores but they're really sweet. The best thing about them is you can enjoy them without guilt because they're fat-free."

Nihla Lake (married, two children at home): "There are some S'more wannabees on the grocers' shelves, but nothing comes close to sitting around a roaring campfire and jamming toasted marshmallow between graham crackers and Hershey bar sections.

"We offered these cookies to our son and his friends and they politely said, `They're OK,' but they didn't ask for S'more. I am not a chocolate lover and my husband thought that the marshmallow was a little tough."

View Comments

Linda C. Tingey (single mother, two teenage boys at home): "TheKeebler elves really have a winner here! These S'mores taste better than the real thing. And you miss all the mess. (Unless you take them with you in the car so the teenagers don't eat them all and they melt!).

"But those of you having to watch fat beware - 11 percent total fat. But I ate them anyway. The S'mores leave you wanting S'more!"

Rich Firmage (married, four children, oldest 10 years old): "These disappeared in a hurry. No one really thought they tasted a whole lot like S'mores, but they were really good anyway."

Conclusion: Hmmm. Are these cookies fat-free? One tester says yea and one says nay. Almost all of them decided they'd like S'more though! We think those elves worked a little magic with a campfire favorite.

Join the Conversation
Looking for comments?
Find comments in their new home! Click the buttons at the top or within the article to view them — or use the button below for quick access.